Energy Consumption in Hospital Buildings: Functional and Morphological Evaluations of Six Case Studies

AUTHOR(S):

M. Coccagna, S. Cesari, P. Valdiserri, P. Romio, S. Mazzacane

TITLE

Energy Consumption in Hospital Buildings: Functional and Morphological Evaluations of Six Case Studies

ABSTRACT

Whilst accounting for 7,5% of the total built area within the non-residential sector [1], hospitals are responsible for 10% of the total energy use in Europe [2] and are estimated to contribute roughly 5% of the carbon dioxide emissions [3]. Healthcare facilities are characterised by an extremely high demand for electricity, heating and cooling throughout the year. In addition to this, the steady changes in the procedures of care delivery, due to the fast-moving advances of the diagnostic techniques, require the continuous remodelling of the existing spaces in operative structures, involving both architectural-distributive aspects and the building plant systems. This process deeply impacts hospital energy consumption, underlining the need of forecasting these new dynamics also in terms of costs. Against this background, the aim of the work consists in the development of a numerical model for the annual energy consumption assessment of six hospitals located in the province of Bologna (Italy), in relation to the different departments, the type of HVAC system, the morphological features of the buildings and the levels of insulation, the ventilation and humidification rates, etc. The numerical model was then tested for each healthcare facility through the use of instruments for the continuous monitoring of the real hospital energy usage. The model allows to forecast the energy consumptions related to the refurbishment or modification of existing hospitals, exploring the impact of architectural and functional features, as well as of energy goals. The main aspect of the work is represented by the methodological framework, which has been based on the identification of the energy needs and consumptions from micro (single spaces) to macro scale (macro-area). In this paper are reported the preliminary results of the work regarding the morphological aspects of the six hospitals analysed and the distribution of the condition floor area in relation to the type of spaces.

KEYWORDS

Hospitals, Energy Consumption, Morphological Aspects, Functional Features, Measurement, Benchmarking, Prediction, Departments

REFERENCES

[1] European Commission, Energy efficiency, Buildings. https://ec.europa.eu/energy/en/topics/energy-efficiency/buildings (accessed 10.11.17).

[2] M. Economidou et al., Europe’s buildings under the microscope - A country-by-country review of the energy performance of buildings, BPIE, Brussels, BE, 2011.

[3] LCB Healthcare, Low Carbon Buildings in the Healthcare Sector, State of the Art Report, 2011.

[4] International Energy Agency (IEA), Transition to sustainable buildings: Strategies and opportunities to 2050, OECD/IEA, 2013.

[5] U.S. DoE, International Energy Outlook 2016, US Energy Information Administration (EIA) Report Number: DOE/EIA-0484, 2016.

[6] J. Grözinger, T. Boermans, A. John, F. Wehringer, J. Seehusen, Overview of Member States information on NZEBs: Background paper – final report, Ecofys, 2014.

[7] O.B. Kazanci, M. Skrupskelis, P. Sevela, G.K. Pavlov, B.W. Olesen, Sustainable heating, cooling and ventilation of a plus-energy house via photovoltaic/thermal panels, Energy and Buildings, Vol. 83, 2014, pp.122-129.

[8] Energy Efficiency Trends and Policies in the Household and Tertiary Sectors: An Analysis Based on the ODYSSEE and MURE Databases, 2015. http://www.odyssee-mure.eu/publications/br/energy-efficiency-trends-policies-buildings.pdf (accessed 10.11.17).

[9] European Commission, EU Buildings Datamapper, Share of non-residential in total building floor area. https://ec.europa.eu/energy/en/eu-buildings-datamapper (accessed 11.11.17).

[10] G.K. Alexis, P. Liakos, A case study of a cogeneration system for a hospital in Greece. Economic and environmental impacts, Applied Thermal Engineering, Vol. 54, No.2, 2013, pp.488-496.

[11] M.J. Eckelman, J. Sherman, Environmental impacts of the U.S. health care system and effects on public health, PLoS One, Vol. 11, No.6, 2016.

[12] S. Schimschar, J. Grözinger, H. Korte, T. Boermans, V. Lilova, R. Bhar, Panorama of the European non-residential construction sector, Ecofys, 2011. http://www.leonardo-energy.com/sites/leonardo-energy/files/documents-and-links/European non-residential building stock - Final Report_v7.pdf (accessed 11.11.17).

[13] Ministero della Salute, Nuovo Sistema Informativo Sanitario (NSIS), Elenco Aziende sanitarie locali e Strutture di ricovero. http://www.salute.gov.it/portale/documentazione/p6_2_8_1_1.jsp?id=13, 2017 (accessed 12.11.17).

[14] B.C. Singer, W.F. Tschudi, High performance healthcare buildings: a roadmap to improved energy efficiency, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 2009.

[15] V. Čongradac, B. Prebiračević, N. Jorgovanović, D. Stanišić, Assessing the energy consumption for heating and cooling in hospitals, Energy and Buildings, Vo. 48, 2012, pp.146-154.

[16] A. Buonomano, F. Calise, G. Ferruzzi, A. Palombo, Dynamic energy performance analysis: Case study for energy efficiency retrofits of hospital buildings, Energy, Vol.78, 2014, pp.555-572.

[17] J. Bujak, Heat consumption for preparing domestic hot water in hospitals, Energy and Buildings, Vol.42, No.7, 2010, pp.1047-1055.

[18] F. Salata, I. Golasi, M. di Salvatore, A. de Lieto Vollaro, Energy and reliability optimization of a system that combines daylighting and artificial sources. A case study carried out in academic buildings, Applied Energy, Vol.169, 2016, pp.250-266.

[19] T. Rohde, R. Martinez, Equipment and energy usage in a large teaching hospital in Norway, Journal of Healthcare Engineering, Vol.6, No.3, 2015, pp.419-33.

[20] N. Christiansen, M. Kaltschmitt, F. Dzukowski, Electrical energy consumption and utilization time analysis of hospital departments and large scale medical equipment, Energy and Buildings, Vol.131, 2016, pp.172-183.

[21] P. Morgenstern, M. Li, R. Raslan, P. Ruyssevelt, A. Wright, Benchmarking acute hospitals: Composite electricity targets based on departmental consumption intensities?, Energy and Buildings, Vol.118, 2016, pp.277-290.

[22] N. Christiansen, M. Kaltschmitt, F. Dzukowski, F. Isensee, Electricity consumption of medical plug loads in hospital laboratories: Identification, evaluation, prediction and verification, Energy and Buildings, Vol.107, 2015, pp.392-406.

[23] The World Bank. Health expenditure, total (% of GDP) | Data. http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.XPD.TOTL.ZS, 2014 (accessed 12.11.17).

[24] ASHRAE, Advanced Energy Design Guide for Small Hospitals and Healthcare Facilities: 30% Energy Savings, ASHRAE, 2009.

[25] CIBSE TM54, Evaluating operational energy performance of buildings at the design stage, Chartered Institution of Building Services Engineers, CIBSE, 2013. http://www.cibse.org/Knowledge/knowledge-items/detail?id=a0q20000008I7f7AAC (accessed 12.11.17).

[26] CarbonBuzz. http://www.carbonbuzz.org/sectorbreakdown.jsp?id=4 (accessed 12.11.17).

[27] A.C. Menezes, A. Cripps, D. Bouchlaghem, R. Buswell, Predicted vs. actual energy performance of non-domestic buildings: Using post-occupancy evaluation data to reduce the performance gap, Applied Energy, Vol.97, 2012, pp.355-364.

[28] P. de Wilde, The gap between predicted and measured energy performance of buildings: A framework for investigation, Automation in Construction, Vol.41, 2014, pp.40-49.

[29] F. Ascione, N. Bianco, C. De Stasio, G.M. Mauro, G.P. Vanoli, Multi-stage and multi-objective optimization for energy retrofitting a developed hospital reference building: A new approach to assess cost-optimality, Applied Energy, Vol.174, 2016, pp.37-68.

[30] Z.A. Adamu, A.D.F. Price, M.J. Cook, Performance evaluation of natural ventilation strategies for hospital wards – A case study of Great Ormond Street Hospital, Building and Environment, Vol.56, 2012, pp.211-222.

[31] T. Tsoutsos, E. Aloumpi, Z. Gkouskos, M. Karagiorgas, Design of a solar absorption cooling system in a Greek hospital, Energy and Buildings, Vol.42, No.2, 2010, pp.265-272.

[32] A. Buonomano, U. Montanaro, A. Palombo, S. Santini, Dynamic building energy performance analysis: A new adaptive control strategy for stringent thermohygrometric indoor air requirements, Applied Energy, Vol.163, 2016, pp.361-386.

[33] ASHRAE, Advanced Energy Design Guide for Large Hospitals. Achieving 50% Energy Savings Toward a Net Zero Energy Building, ASHRAE, 2012.

[34] E. Bonnema, M. Leach, S. Pless, Technical Support Document: Development of the Advanced Energy Design Guide for Large Hospitals – 50% Energy Savings, NREL, 2013.

[35] E. Bonnema, D. Studer, A. Parker, S. Pless, P. Torcellini, Large Hospital 50% Energy Savings: Technical Support Document, NREL, 2010.

[36] E. Bonnema, S. Pless, I. Doebber, P. Torcellini, Technical Support Document: Development of the Advanced Energy Design Guide for Small Hospitals and Healthcare Facilities - 30% Guide, NREL, 2010.

[37] H. Burpee, J. Loveland, Targeting 100! Envisioning the high performance hospital: implications for a new, low energy, high performance prototype, University of Washington, 2010.

[38] C.A. Short, K.J. Lomas, R. Giridharan, A.J. Fair, Building resilience to overheating into 1960’s UK hospital buildings within the constraint of the national carbon reduction target: Adaptive strategies, Building and Environment, Vol.55, 2012, pp.73-95.

[39] K.J. Lomas, R. Giridharan, Thermal comfort standards, measured internal temperatures and thermal resilience to climate change of free-running buildings: A case-study of hospital wards, Building and Environment, Vol.55, 2012, pp.57-72.

[40] F. Ascione, N. Bianco, R.F. De Masi, G.P. Vanoli, Rehabilitation of the building envelope of hospitals: Achievable energy savings and micro-climatic control on varying the HVAC systems in Mediterranean climates, Energy and Buildings, Vol.60, 2013, pp.125-138.

[41] M. Ahmadzadehtalatapeh, Y.H. Yau, The application of heat pipe heat exchangers to improve the air quality and reduce the energy consumption of the air conditioning system in a hospital ward - A full year model simulation, Energy and Buildings, Vol.43, 2011, pp.2344-2355.

[42] G. Pagliarini, C. Corradi, S. Rainieri, Hospital CHCP system optimization assisted by TRNSYS building energy simulation tool, Applied Thermal Engineering, Vol.44, 2012, pp.150-158.

[43] D.B. do E. Santo, An energy and exergy analysis of a high-efficiency engine trigeneration system for a hospital: A case study methodology based on annual energy demand profiles, Energy and Buildings, Vol.76, 2014, pp.185-198.

[44] A. Malkawi, G. Augenbroe, Advanced building simulation, Spon Press, 2003.

[45] D. Kolokotsa, D. Rovas, E. Kosmatopoulos, K. Kalaitzakis, A roadmap towards intelligent net zero- and positive-energy buildings, Solar Energy, Vol. 85, No.12, 2011, pp.3067-3084.

[46] V. Čongradac, B. Prebiračević, N. Petrovački, Methods for assessing energy savings in hospitals using various control techniques, Energy and Buildings, Vol.69, 2014, pp.85-92.

[47] A. Bagnasco, F. Fresi, M. Saviozzi, F. Silvestro, A. Vinci, Electrical consumption forecasting in hospital facilities: An application case, Energy and Buildings, Vol.103, 2015, pp.261-270.

[48] A.L. Zorita, M.A. Fernández-Temprano, L.-A. García-Escudero, O. Duque-Perez, A statistical modeling approach to detect anomalies in energetic efficiency of buildings, Energy and Buildings, Vol.110, 2016, pp.377-386.

[49] C.R. Iddon, T.C. Mills, R. Giridharan, K.J. Lomas, The influence of hospital ward design on resilience to heat waves: An exploration using distributed lag models, Energy and Buildings, Vol.86, 2015, pp.573-588.

[50] C.A. Balaras, E. Dascalaki, A. Gaglia, HVAC and indoor thermal conditions in hospital operating rooms, Energy and Buildings, Vol.39, 2007, pp.454-470.

[51] A. Gimelli, M. Muccillo, Optimization criteria for cogeneration systems: Multi-objective approach and application in an hospital facility, Applied Energy, Vol.104, 2013, pp.910-923.

[52] H. Cho, A.D. Smith, P. Mago, Combined cooling, heating and power: A review of performance improvement and optimization, Applied Energy, Vol.136, 2014, pp.168-185.

[53] Agenzia Nazionale per i Servizi Sanitari Regionali, Progetto di ricerca finalizzata (ex art. 12, Dlgs 502/92), Principi guida tecnici, organizzativi e gestionali per la realizzazione e gestione di ospedali ad alta tecnologia e assistenza, Monitor. Supplement to n. 6, 2003.

[54] N. Setola, Percorsi, flussi e persone nella progettazione ospedaliera: l’analisi configurazionale, teoria e applicazione, Firenze University Press, 2013.

[55] R. Palumbo, Metaprogettazione per l’edilizia ospedaliera, BE-MA, 1993.

[56] F. Rossi Prodi, A. Stocchetti, L’architettura dell’ospedale, Alinea, 1990.

[57] Enciclopedia medica italiana, Vol.10, USES, 1983.

[58] R. Choudhary, Energy analysis of the non-domestic building stock of Greater London, Building and Environment, Vol.51, 2012, No.243-254.

[59] K.J. Lomas, Y. Ji, Resilience of naturally ventilated buildings to climate change: Advanced natural ventilation and hospital wards, Energy and Buildings, Vol.41, 2009, pp.629-653.

[60] B.C. Singer, P. Mathew, S. Greenberg, W. Tschudi, D. Sartor, S. Strom, W. Vernon, M. Nash, L. Burch, Hospital Energy Benchmarking Guidance -Version 1.0 LBNL Report, Berkeley, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 2009.

[61] A. Teke, O. Timur, Assessing the energy efficiency improvement potentials of HVAC systems considering economic and environmental aspects at the hospitals, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, Vol. 33, 2014, pp.224-235.

[62] OECD, OECD Health Statistics 2017, OECD Publishing, 2017, http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/health-data-en.

[63] OECD, Health at a Glance 2017: OECD Indicators, Hospital beds, OECD, 2017.

[64] Eurostat, Hospital beds, 2017. http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php/Healthcare_resource_statistics_-_beds (accessed 12.11.17).

Cite this paper

M. Coccagna, S. Cesari, P. Valdiserri, P. Romio, S. Mazzacane. (2017) Energy Consumption in Hospital Buildings: Functional and Morphological Evaluations of Six Case Studies. International Journal of Environmental Science, 2, 443-452